Glen Hansard & Marketa Irglova "Falling Slowly"
BackGlen Hansard (of The Frames) & Marketa Irglova perform "Falling Slowly" live in Chicago. " The song is featured in the film "Once." The film, starring Hansard and Irglova and directed by John Carney, won the World Cinema Audience Award for Dramatic Film at the 2007 Sundance Film Festival and is currently enjoying a successful worldwide release.
Channel: Music
Uploaded: January 29, 2007 at 11:55 am
Author: frames2007
Length: 0:05:35
Rating: 4.89
Views: 985,018
Tags: glen hansard marketa irglova once falling slowly frames swell season overcoat sundance
Video Comments:
YouSpamTard (Friday 21st of November 2008 08:19:41 AM)
My latest thesis. People hear a song and it moves them. They presume the music was made from the feeling they get when listening to it. Relatively speaking, this is not the case. The song creates the feeling. Feeling does not create the song. For instance, I can record automobile traffic, or fingernails on a chalk board. Both recordings will create a "feeling", but feeling did not create the traffic or the fingernails on the chalk board. This is why music sucks today. Ass backwards approach.
YouSpamTard (Friday 21st of November 2008 07:58:34 AM)
MrCauthon, Yes, there are maybe 5 people in this world that know as much about music as I do. That is correct. If you don't believe it, well test my knowledge. My "opinion", is from 47 years of intense music study, and a "heart" felt passion for it. Yes, I agree that this song makes people feel "nice and fuzzy". Why is this? How has this happened? I can clearly prove this is not music, but it is nice an fuzzy to some. To me it is nauseating. You know so much, please explain why this is? I can.
MrCauthon (Friday 21st of November 2008 07:50:12 AM)
"There are maybe 5 in this world that know what I know about music." (pg 4 atm)
You're stating your opinion as fact on every page here.
Most people probably came here to say they felt some nice fuzzy feeling inside while listening to this, those feelings happened and that can't be argued regardless of your personal opinion or music theory. You insisting in 90 posts to try to discredit that makes you look foolish and arrogant
Reflect instead of trying to win the argument, Now I'm really done.
YouSpamTard (Friday 21st of November 2008 07:31:41 AM)
MrCauthin. You, like most, read from the many paragraphs I write, and seemingly walk away with not a single inclination of my very literal distinctions concerning music and specifically this song. You say: "you claim the supremacy of your subjective opinion based on the ludicrous claim that you're one of the most knowledgeable people on the planet". Where the hell did you get that from? I did not say that. If you feel like you should comment, at least have the curtsy to read my text first.
MrCauthon (Friday 21st of November 2008 06:15:43 AM)
No that's not it, you're entitled to an opinion and that's exactly the point of everyones disagreement with you, you claim the supremacy of your subjective opinion based on the ludicrous claim that you're one of the most knowledgeable people on the planet. It's such a dumb argument it could only happen on Youtube and my part is done, at least I tried explaining the error of your ways. best regards.
YouSpamTard (Thursday 20th of November 2008 07:00:53 AM)
MrCauthon. I once heard a record producer say music takes three things:
1)Talent. I guess you could consider this "feel" for music as well.
2)Technique. This would be the physical playing of the instrument itself.
3)Knowledge. This is anything in the brain that can be relied on as a substance of cognitive thought. It may include musical education.
We have hearts and minds that work "together". I think what's in your heart is that you hate me because I don't like this sing. How silly is that?
YouSpamTard (Thursday 20th of November 2008 06:48:27 AM)
Ber3t. Is this what you do? Find people on tube, put words in their mouth, speculate as to what they say, rather than actually read what they say, then gather large irrelevant leaps of of cognition and sum it all up with a "Fuck You! Best regards mate.." I have noticed utube seems to actually teach this sort of hostility. So, on a personal note, because you have personally left me a friendly "fuck you", I will say caution. Hostility aimed toward me, is an indicator of something going on with you
Ber3t (Wednesday 19th of November 2008 05:11:54 PM)
That was to YouSpamTurd
Ber3t (Wednesday 19th of November 2008 05:09:08 PM)
I know this is pretty old, but i want to say a few things. If you think that way(music is math and science over heart) I feel sorry for you. Oh, and if by accident You can't play any musical instrument, Fuck You! Best regards mate..
flyff4eva (Thursday 13th of November 2008 04:42:00 PM)
asome song!!!